Fulfilling international obligations of the Republic of Kazakhstan toward achieving carbon neutrality: Legal challenges and prospects
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/ee.16(4).2025.01
-
Article InfoVolume 16 2025, Issue #4, pp. 1-14
- 10 Views
-
1 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Type of the article: Research Article
Abstract
Many countries face the need for structural transformation of their economies, particularly in terms of environmental and climate aspects. Global decarbonization initiatives have forced Kazakhstan to revise its economic policy priorities as well as legal regulation in several spheres. The objective of this study was to identify the existing legal challenges confronting Kazakhstan in fulfilling its international commitments to achieve carbon neutrality. The methodological basis is presented by political and legal analysis. Persistent issues in Kazakhstan’s pursuit of carbon neutrality include the absence of clear and transparent mechanisms for allocating CO₂ emissions quotas, insufficient harmonization with international law, poor institutional coordination, and a lack of legal instruments to incentivize businesses and ensure public participation. Some decarbonization decisions conflict with other government programs and priorities, such as plans to increase hydrocarbon production. From a formal legal perspective, the key challenges for Kazakhstan include unclear mechanisms for implementing the Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC), the absence of legal tools for abandoning fossil fuels, insufficient transparency of the NDC, and weak formalization of the consultation mechanism with stakeholders (including NGOs and the private sector). Among the challenges identified, there are an absence of an institutional basis for the functioning of a single center for managing climate policy, problems of law enforcement, as well as a lack of generalized judicial practice.
Acknowledgment
This research has been/was/is funded by the Science Committee of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Grant No. AP23490668). Project IRN AP23490668 “Legal aspects of processing and disposal of solid municipal waste in the Republic of Kazakhstan: problems and prospects”.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)Q01, K20
-
References67
-
Tables0
-
Figures0
-
- 24kz. (2024, November 12). Uglerodnaya neytralnost: Сhto predprinimayet Kazakhstan [Carbon neutrality: What Kazakhstan is doing]. (In Russian).
- Abibulloeva, A., & Amanbaiuly, M. (2024). Youth involvement in climate issues in Kazakhstan and Tajikistan: Illusion or reality? CABAR.
- Aubakirova, G. M., Biryukov, V. V., Isataeva, F. M., & Mazhitova, S. K. (2023a). Dekarbonizatsiya ekonomiki Kazakhstana: Perspektivy energeticheskogo perekhoda [Decarbonization of Kazakhstan’s economy: Energy transition prospects]. Economy: Strategy and Practice, 18(4), 55-72. (In Russian).
- Aubakirova, G. M., Isataeva, F. M., & Biryukov, V. V. (2025). Prioritetnyye napravleniya dekarbonizatsii energeticheskogo sektora Kazakhstana [Priority directions for decarbonizing Kazakhstan’s energy sector]. Central Asian Economic Review, 5, 6-19. (In Russian).
- Aubakirova, G. M., Isataeva, F. M., Mazhitova, S. K., & Togaibayeva, L. I. (2023b). Dekarbonizatsiya gorno-metallurgicheskogo sektora: Opyt Kazakhstan [Decarbonization of the mining and metallurgical sector: Kazakhstan’s experience]. Turan University Bulletin, 4, 54-69. (In Russian).
- Azertag. (2024). Kazakhstan predstavil na COP29 plany po dostizheniyu uglerodnoy neytralnosti [Kazakhstan presents plans for achieving carbon neutrality at COP29]. (In Russian).
- Bakunkin, A. N. (2022). Ekologizatsiya zakonodatelstva Respubliki Kazakhstan o vozobnovlyayemykh istochnikakh energii: Novyye vyzovy na puti k dekarbonizatsii [Ecologization of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on renewable energy sources: New challenges on the path to decarbonization]. Sustainable Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the Context of Transition to the “Green Economy”, 1, 125-127. (In Russian).
- Bala, R., Singh, S., & Grima, K. S. S. (2025). Sustainable Finance and Investment Analytics: a Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis Approach. Journal of Economic Sciences: Theory and Practice, 82(2), 89-106.
- Begimbay, K., Myrzakhmet, M., & Radoshevich, S. (2024). Stsenarnoye prognozirovaniye kak instrument strategicheskogo planirovaniya v obrabatyvayushchey promyshlennosti: Teoreticheskiyeosnovyi metodologicheskiyepodkhody [Scenario forecasting as a tool for strategic planning in the manufacturing industry: Theoretical foundations and methodological approaches]. International Scientific and Practical Conference “Industrial Policy and Development of Manufacturing Industry: New Methodologies, Foreign Experience and Concepts for Kazakhstan” ALMATAU SYMPOSIUM 2024 (pp. 5-15). Almaty Management University. (In Russian).
- Bertaeva, K., Onaltaev, D., Bakhyt, Y., Kozhakhmetova, M., & Mukhametzhanova, Z. (2024). Green bond market in Kazakhstan: Problems and prospects. In M. Shamtsyan & I. Kulova (Eds.), International Scientific Conference on Biotechnology and Food Technology (BFT-2024) (vol. 130, p. 08026). Saint Petersburg: EDP Sciences.
- Biresselioglu, M. E., Savas, Z. F., & Solak, B. (2023). The dilemma between carbon neutrality and energy security: Understanding the likely impacts of the Covid-19 and the Russia–Ukraine war on the EU climate targets. In E. Akıllı & B. Gunes (Eds.), World Politics in the Age of Uncertainty: The Covid-19 Pandemic (vol. 1, pp. 59-73). Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland.
- Bocharova, M. (2019). Manipulyatsiya. Okolo 75% territorii RK podverzheny risku ekologicheskoy destabilizatsii [Manipulation. About 75% of the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan is at risk of environmental destabilization]. (In Russian).
- Chen, L., Msigwa, G., Yang, M., Osman, A. I., Fawzy, S., Rooney, D. W., & Yap, P. S. (2022). Strategies to achieve a carbon neutral society: A review. Environmental Chemistry Letters, 20(4), 2277-2310.
- Climate Action Tracker. (n.d.). Kazakhstan. Country summary.
- Climate Net of Central Asia. (2023, December 28). Nepraktichno soprotivlyat’sya tomu, chto neizbezhno – Gulmira Ismagulova o promedlenii Kazakhstana v prinyatii effektivnoy klimaticheskoy politiki [It is impractical to resist what is inevitable – Gulmira Ismagulova on Kazakhstan’s delay in adopting effective climate policy]. (In Russian).
- Davtyan, V. S., & Khachikyan, S. R. (2024a). Comparative analysis of energy system greening in the EAEU: Prospects for energy transition. RUDN Journal of Economics, 32(3), 447-469.
- Davtyan, V. S., & Khachikyan, S. R. (2024b). Decarbonization policy in the Eurasian economic union: Meeting the challenge of global climate change (comparative analysis). Bulletin of Yerevan University D: International Relations and Political Sciences, 15(3.45), 35-49.
- de las Heras, B. P. (2024). EU green transition in times of geopolitical pressures: Accelerating or slowing the pace towards climate neutrality? European Journal of Sustainable Development, 13(2).
- Doczi, S. (2024). Net Zero Energy by 2060: Charting the Path of Europe and Central Asia toward a Secure and Sustainable Energy Future. Livewire.
- Du, H., & Zhang, H. (2022). Climate neutrality in the EU and China: An analysis of the stringency of targets and the adaptiveness of the relevant legal frameworks. Review of European, Comparative & International Environmental Law, 31(3), 495-509.
- Esirkepova, A. M., Niyazbekova, R. K., & Mahmood, D. M. (2024). Study of the activities of peasant farms in Kazakhstan in the context of efficient energy consumption. Bulletin of the NAS RK, 411(5), 318-329.
- Evro, S., Oni, B. A., & Tomomewo, O. S. (2024). Global strategies for a low-carbon future: lessons from the US, China, and EU’s pursuit of carbon neutrality. Journal of Cleaner Production, 461, Article 142635.
- Fu, Y., & Zhu, Y. (2024). The international legal path to carbon neutrality under the sustainable development goals. Lecture Notes in Education Psychology and Public Media, 44, 82-89.
- Galiev, S., Yessekina, B., Beisengazin, K., & Nurushev, D. (2024). Prioritety tekhnologicheskoy modernizatsii dlya dostizheniya uglerodnoy neytralnosti ekonomiki Kazakhstana [Priorities of technological modernization to achieve carbon neutrality of the economy of Kazakhstan]. Public Administration and Civil Service, 3(90), 160-168. (In Russian).
- Gogoleva, T. N., Kostyleva, V. I., Shchepina, I. N., & Shishkina, N. V. (2024). Mirovoy opyt primeneniya sistem torgovli razresheniyami na vybrosy: Teoreticheskiy i empiricheskiy analiz [Global experience in the application of emission trading systems: Theoretical and empirical analysis]. Sovremennaya Ekonomika: Problemy i Resheniya – Modern Economy: Issues and Solutions, 2, 6-18. (In Russian).
- Guo, Y., Yang, Y., Bradshaw, M., Wang, C., & Blondeel, M. (2023). Globalization and decarbonization: Changing strategies of global oil and gas companies. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 14(6), Article e849.
- Han, L., Zhou, Z., Shi, B., & Wang, Y. (2024). Challenges to environmental governance arising from the Russo–Ukrainian conflict: Evidence from carbon emissions. Journal of Environmental Management, 349, Article 119481.
- He, X. (2024). China’s adaptation governance in a world of carbon neutrality. China-EU Law Journal.
- Horani, H. U. R., Amin, M., & Ahmed, F. (2025). Climate Risk Insurance: Bibliometric Review on Present, Past and Future. Journal of Economic Sciences: Theory & Practice, 82(1), 4-18.
- Karpuntsov, V., & Veresha, R. (2022a). Criminal and administrative aspects of the sociology of law: Opportunities for expanding the research and the field of expertise. InterEULawEast: Journal for the international and european law, economics and market integrations, 9(1), 147-165.
- Karpuntsov, V., & Veresha, R. (2022b). The issues of criminological and victimological security and the COVID-19-related quarantine measures. Journal of Emergency Management, 20(4), 301-315.
- Kazakevich, A., Hodgson, R., Frost, R., & Orlandi, G. (2024). COP29 v Baku: Soglasheniye dostignuto, no mnogiye razocharovany [COP29 in Baku: Agreement reached, but many disappointed]. Euro News. (In Russian).
- Khalabuzar, N. (2024, July 10). Raskalennyye goroda Kazakhstana: Chto pokazyvayet teplovaya karta? [Kazakhstan’s hot cities: What does the heat map show?]. RednewsKZ. (In Russian).
- Kolosovskaya, K. (2024, September 7). Ugol, klimat i Parizhskoye soglasheniye: Kak Kazakhstan dvizhetsya k realizatsii mirovoy idei [Coal, climate and the Paris Agreement: How Kazakhstan is moving towards the implementation of the global idea]. Ulys Media. (In Russian).
- Kuur, O. V., Varavin, E. V., & Kozlova, M. V. (2024). Faktory ESG-transformatsii ekonomiki Kazakhstana v kontekste ustoychivogo razvitiya [ESG transformation factors of Kazakhstan’s economy in the context of sustainable development]. Economy: Strategy and Practice, 19(2), 20-40. (In Russian).
- Lifshits, I. M., Smbatyan, A. S., & Salia, M. R. (2024). Implementation of the Paris climate agreement in the legal systems of EAEU member states. Lex Russica, 77(1), 103-118.
- Nukusheva, A., Ilyassova, G., Rustembekova, D., Zhamiyeva, R., & Arenova, L. (2021). Global warming problem faced by the international community: International legal aspect. International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics, 21(2), 219-233.
- Nukusheva, A., Rustembekova, D., Abdizhami, A., Au, T., & Kozhantayeva, Z. (2023). Regulatory obstacles in municipal solid waste management in Kazakhstan in comparison with the EU. Sustainability, 15(2), Article 1034.
- Official Information Resource of the Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2021). Do 2060 goda Kazakhstan pereydet na uglerodnuyu neytralnost [Kazakhstan will switch to carbon neutrality by 2060]. (In Russian).
- Partnership for Action on Green Economy (PAGE). (2020). Kazakhstan’s transition to a Green Economy: A stocktaking report.
- Perissi, I., & Jones, A. (2022). Investigating European Union decarbonization strategies: Evaluating the pathway to carbon neutrality by 2050. Sustainability, 14(8), Article 4728.
- President of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2023). Decree of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 121 of February 2, 2023, “On Approving the Strategy for Achieving Carbon Neutrality of the Republic of Kazakhstan by 2060.” (In Russian).
- Sciberras Bray, N. (2024). The Russian-Ukrainian war and its effects on the European green deal (Bachelor’s Thesis). University of Malta.
- Shestak, V. A., & Postoeva, E. A. (2022). Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost za nezakonnuyu dobychu uglya: rossiyskoye i inostrannoye pravovoye regulirovaniye [Criminal liability for illegal coal mining: Russian and foreign legal regulation]. Ugol, 8, 95-99. (In Russian).
- Shestak, V. A., & Savenkova, P. G. (2023). Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost za nezakonnuyu dobychu poleznykh iskopayemykh v Peru i Ekvadore [Criminalization of illegal mining in Peru and Ecuador]. Ugol, 2, 72-76. (In Russian).
- Shestak, V. A., & Tsyplakova, A. D. (2022). Features of criminal liability for theft of certain energy resources in the UK. Ugol, 10, 72-76. (In Russian).
- Shogentsukova, Z. K., & Lepshekova, R. R. (2024). Ekologicheskiy komplayens v ramkakh klimaticheskoy povestki [Environmental compliance in the climate agenda framework]. International Agricultural Journal, 65(6), 1839-1861. (In Russian).
- Shugurov, M. V. (2024). Gosudarstva – Chleny YEAES i zelenyy klimaticheskiy fond: Perspektivy skoordinirovannogo vzaimodeystviya v sfere klimaticheskogo finansirovaniya [EAEU member states and the green climate fund: Prospects for coordinated climate finance cooperation]. International Law and International Organizations, 2, 12-50. (In Russian).
- Sikora, A. (2021). European green deal–legal and financial challenges of the climate change. Era Forum, 21(4), 681-697.
- Sopykhanova, A., Maytanov, A., Kiseleva, A., & Zhamiyeva, R. (2023). Problems of legal regulation and state policy measures related to nature management in the framework of achieving the SDGs: Examples from Russia and Kazakhstan. Sustainability, 15(2), Article 1042.
- Sulaimanova, B., Sharshenova, A., & Sabyrbekov, R. (2024). Digitalization of Infrastructure and Decarbonization in Central Asia: Opportunities and Challenges. Central Asia Regional Economic Cooperation (CAREC) Institute.
- Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2024). Obzory sudebnoy praktiki [Reviews of judicial practice]. (In Russian).
- The World Bank. (2023). Diagnostika Gornorudnogo Sektora – Kazakhstan [Mining Sector Diagnostics – Kazakhstan]. (In Russian).
- Tick, A., Akaev, A., Devezas, T. C., Sarygulov, A., Petryakov, A., & Evgenevich, A. I. (2024). Assessing decarbonization approaches across major economies. Energies, 17(17), Article 4381.
- Tolochko, O. H. (2024a). Improving EAEU legal norms for greening transport systems. Bulletin of the Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan, 4(79), 187-195.
- Tolochko, О. Н. (2024b). The role of EAEU law in the decarbonization of energy systems of the member states and sustainable development of the green economy. Bulletin of the Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan, 2(77), 238-246.
- Tonkonog, O. (2024). Minekologii vybirayet birzhu dlya torgov kvotami na vybrosy [The Ministry of Ecology chooses an exchange for trading emission quotas]. Kursiv. (In Russian).
- UN. (2021). All about NDCs.
- UN. (2024). NDC Registry.
- UNESCO. (2024). Sweden. Climate Change Communication and Education.
- Xenarios, S., Sembayeva, A., Tsani, S., Orazagaliyev, S., & Ansaganova, Z. (2024). Clean energy challenges and innovation opportunities in Kazakhstan. Environmental Research Communications, 6(11), Article 115009.
- Yesekina, B., Khoroshilova, D., & Safonov, M. (2024). Kazakhstan: Uluchshaya klimaticheskoye zakonodatelstvo [Kazakhstan: Improving climate legislation]. Eurasia NET. (In Russian).
- Zarubina, V. R., Zarubin, M. Y., Esenkulova, Z. Z., & Pritula, R. A. (2024). Prodvizheniye ESG-povestki dlya malogo i srednego predprinimatel‘stva Respubliki Kazakhstan v usloviyakh ustoychivogo razvitiya [Advancing the ESG agenda for small and medium enterprises in Kazakhstan within sustainable development]. Turan University Bulletin, 3, 84-97.
- Zhakiyev, N., Sagadatova, N., Ismagulova, G., Bakdolotov, A., & Biloshchytskyi, A. (2024). Hybrid technico-economical modeling of the mid-term green economy and low-carbon development strategy of Kazakhstan. ES Energy & Environment, 25.
- Zhang, Z., Hu, G., Mu, X., & Kong, L. (2022). From low carbon to carbon neutrality: A bibliometric analysis of the status, evolution and development trend. Journal of Environmental Management, 322, Article 116087.
- Zhao, X., Ma, X., Chen, B., Shang, Y., & Song, M. (2022). Challenges toward carbon neutrality in China: Strategies and countermeasures. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 176, Article 105959.
- Zheng, Y., Li, Z., & Chai, J. (2023). Progress and prospects of international carbon peaking and carbon neutral research–based on bibliometric analysis (1991–2022). Frontiers in Energy Research, 11, Article 1121639.