Debt-for-nature or climate swaps in public finance management
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/ppm.21(3).2023.54
-
Article InfoVolume 21 2023, Issue #3, pp. 698-713
- Cited by
- 662 Views
-
286 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Considering climate change and growing ecological threats, achieving climate neutrality requires close attention from the state and the involvement of new tools, including those of the so-called green financing. This paper aims to determine the feasibility of combining the tasks of reducing the debt burden and expanding investments in environmental programs in Ukraine, using innovative tools for public finance management, such as debt-for-nature and debt-for-climate swaps. It substantiated the necessity of coordinating debt-for-environment investment programs within the framework of Ukraine’s National Recovery Plan and initiatives implemented in Ukraine with the active participation of the World Bank Group. The advantages of this approach are ensuring clear interaction with international financial institutions and expanding the practice of greening public management.
Based on statistical data for 2009–2022, the results demonstrate the growth of negative debt dynamics and characterize limited financing environmental restoration in Ukraine. Relying on international practices, the study conducted a comparative analysis to identify the most significant characteristics of the new debt green conversion instruments as well as the advantages and limitations of their use in Ukraine. The paper offers scenarios for implementing the concept of debt-for-nature exchange in the conditions of Ukraine. It shows the result of the formation of a new debt payment profile. These findings can raise state authorities’ awareness of making proper decisions regarding debt policy and public finance management.
Acknowledgment
The study presents the results of a study conducted as part of the scientific project “Formation of the foundations of nationally rooted stability and security of the economic development of Ukraine in the conditions of the hybrid “peace-war” system” (state registration number 0123U100965).
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)H61, Q56, O13
-
References45
-
Tables4
-
Figures8
-
- Figure 1. Growth in natural capital per capita and GDP per capita (%), 1995–2018
- Figure 2. GDP and state debt dynamics in Ukraine in 2017–2022
- Figure 3. State external debt, foreign exchange reserves, and foreign trade in goods dynamics in Ukraine in 2017–2022
- Figure 4. Illustrative example of bilateral debt-for-nature initiatives
- Figure 5. Illustrative example of a three-party debt-for-nature swap agreement
- Figure 6. Illustration of the movement of financial flows when using debt-for-climate swaps
- Figure 7. The restructuring part of the external state debt in exchange for a commitment to invest in nature as a part of Ukraine’s National Recovery Plan
- Figure 8. Country risk premium and total equity risk premium for Ukraine in 2014–2023
-
- Table 1. Natural capital of Ukraine (in millions USD)*
- Table 2. Ukraine’s sovereign credit ratings
- Table 3. Key characteristics of green debt swaps and their potential impact
- Table 4. Debt profile
-
- Bogdan, Т., & Lomakovych, V. (2021). Financialization of the global economy: Macroeconomic implications and policy challenges for Ukraine. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 18(1), 151-164.
- Brears, R. C. (2023). Debt-for-nature swaps. In R. C. Brears (Ed.), Financing Water Security and Green Growth (pp. 73-88). Oxford Academic.
- Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (CMU). (2017). Pro skhvalennia Enerhetychnoi stratehii Ukrainy na period do 2035 roku “Bezpeka, enerhoefektyvnist, konkurentospromozhnist” [On approval of the Energy Strategy of Ukraine for the period up to 2035 “Security, energy efficiency, competitiveness”]. (In Ukrainian).
- Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (CMU). (2023). Mindovkillya: Vazhlivi rishennya dlya Ukrayinina Bonnskij konferenciyi zi zmini klimatu [Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources: Important decisions for Ukraine at the Bonn Climate Change Conference]. (In Ukrainian).
- Cassimon, D., Prowse, M., & Essers, D. (2011). The pitfalls and potential of debt-for-nature swaps: A US-Indonesian case study. Global Environmental Change, 21(1), 93-102.
- Chamon, M., Klok, E., Thakoor, V., & Zettelmeyer, J. (2022). Debt-for-climate swaps: Analysis, design, and implementation (WP/2022/162). International Monetary Fund.
- Chen, N. (2019, September 18). Green leadership – Belt & Road initiative. Refinitiv.
- Council of the European Union. (2021). Fit for 55 Package. Brussels.
- Damodaran, A. (2022). Country risk: Determinants, measures and implications. NYU Stern.
- European Investment Bank (EIB). (2021). The EIB Climate Adaptation Plan: Supporting the EU Adaptation Strategy to build resilience to climate change.
- Georgieva, K., Chamon, M., & Thakoor, V. (2022, December 14). Swapping debt for climate or nature pledges can help fund resilience. International Monetary Fund.
- Greiner, R., & Lankester, A. (2007). Supporting on-farm biodiversity conservation through debt-for-conservation swaps: Concept and critique. Land Use Policy, 24(2), 458-471.
- Hansen, S. (1989). Debt for nature swaps – Overview and discussion of key issues. Ecological Economics, 1(1), 77-93.
- Kelly, L., Ducros, A., & Steele, P. (2023). Redesigning debt swaps for a more sustainable future (IIED Briefing). International Institute for Environment and Development.
- Losenno, C. (2022, November 12). Delivering on adaptation. European Investment Bank.
- Lovejoy, Т. (1984, October 4). Aid Debtor Nations’ Ecology. The New York Times.
- Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources (MEPNR). (n.d.). ЕkoZagroza [EcoThreat]. (In Ukrainian).
- Ministry of Finance of Ukraine. (2023). Credit Ratings 2023.
- Ministry of Finance of Ukraine. (n.d.a). Debt policy.
- Ministry of Finance of Ukraine. (n.d.b). Derzhavnij borg ta garantovanij derzhavoyu borg [State debt and state guaranteed debt]. (In Ukrainian).
- Mishchenko, S. Naumenkova, S., Mishchenko, V., Ivanov, V., & Lysenko, R. (2019). Growing discoordination between monetary and fiscal policies in Ukraine. Banks and Bank Systems, 14(2), 40-49.
- Mishchenko, V., Naumenkova, S., Grytsenko, A., & Mishchenko, S. (2022). Operational risk management of using electronic and mobile money. Banks and Bank Systems, 17(3), 142-157.
- National Bank of Ukraine (NBU). (2023). Zovnishnij borg Ukrayini na kinec I kvartalu 2023 roku [Ukraine’s external debt at the end of Q1 2023]. (In Ukrainian).
- National Recovery Council. (2022). Ukraine’s National Recovery Plan.
- Naumenkova, S., Mishchenko, V., & Mishchenko, S. (2022). Key energy indicators for sustainable development goals in Ukraine. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 20(1), 379-395.
- Nedopil Wang, C. (2020). Investments in the Chinese Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) in the first half of 2020 during the Covid-19 pandemic. Green BRI Center and International Institute of Green Finance.
- Potier, M. (1991). Debt-for-nature swaps. Land Use Policy, 8(3), 211-213.
- Refinitiv. (2020). BRI connect: An initiative іn numbers (5th ed.).
- Sarkar, A., & Ebbs, K. (1992). A possible solution to tropical troubles? Debt-for-nature swaps. Futures, 24(7), 653-668.
- Sheikh, Р. (2018). Debt-for-Nature Initiatives and the Tropical Forest Conservation Act: Status and implementation. Congressional Research Service, RL31286.
- SSC of Ukraine. (n.d.). Statystyka [Statistics]. (In Ukrainian).
- Steele, P., & Patel, S. (2020). Tackling the triple crisis. Using debt swaps to address debt, climate and nature loss post-COVID-19 (Issue Paper). London: IIED.
- Swanson, E., Niu, R., Zhu, L., Nedopil Wang, C., & Yue, M. (2022). Debt for nature swap. A green finance tool for dealing with overseas sovereign debt. Paulson Institute and Green Finance and Development Center, Fudan University.
- Ukraine Comprehensive Debt Payment Relief Act of 2022, H.R. bill, 7081, 117th Congress. (2022).
- UNDP. (2023). UNDP Signals Spotlight 2023.
- United Nations (UN). (2015). Paris Agreement.
- White, N. (2023a, January 23). Barclays sees real greenwashing risk in ESG debt-swap market. Bloomberg.
- White, N. (2023b, January 11). Wall Street’s new ESG money-maker promises nature conservation – With a catch. Bloomberg.
- World Bank. (2021). The changing wealth of nations 2021: Managing assets for the future.
- World Bank. (2022). New multi-donor trust fund established to channel donor support to Ukraine.
- World Bank. (2023a). Responsible use of natural resources: Essential for sustainable growth.
- World Bank. (2023b). Ukraine relief, recovery, reconstruction and reform trust fund (URTF).
- Yue, M., & Nedopil Wang, C. (2021). Debt-for-nature swaps: A triple-win solution for debt sustainability and biodiversity finance in the Belt and Road initiative (BRI)? IIGF Green BRI Center.
- Zhuravka, F., Filatova, H., & Aiyedogbon, J. (2019). Government debt forecasting based on the Arima model. Public and Municipal Finance, 8(1), 120-127.
- Zhuravka, F., Filatova, H., Šuleř, P., & Wołowiec, T. (2021). State debt assessment and forecasting: Time series analysis. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 18(1), 65-75.