Financial monitoring effectiveness in Kazakhstan’s bank investment operations: A mixed-methods evaluation
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/bbs.20(4).2025.21
-
Article InfoVolume 20 2025, Issue #4, pp. 276-292
- 10 Views
-
1 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Type of the article: Research Article
Abstract
Investment activities of banks are a key driver in financial sector development, yet their effectiveness largely depends on the quality of financial monitoring, which can detect, diagnose, and correct anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT) weaknesses. This article aims to assess the effectiveness of financial monitoring in the investment operations of Kazakhstani banks and to identify transaction-level risk indicators that can support data-driven AML/CFT supervision. The study employs a mixed methods design that combines analysis of national AML/CFT legislation and supervisory guidance with semi-structured expert interviews and case studies of three major institutions (Halyk Bank, Kaspi Bank, and ForteBank). In the quantitative component, a synthetic dataset of 1,000 investment-related transactions, calibrated to 2019–2024 statistics from the National Bank of Kazakhstan and the Committee for Financial Monitoring, is analyzed using logistic, multilevel, and Bayesian logistic regression with cross-validation and bootstrapped confidence intervals. The models achieve high predictive performance (AUC up to 0.93, test accuracy up to 93.2%, sensitivity 82.0%, specificity 94.1%) and show that higher transaction amounts, cross-border origin, SWIFT channel use, and investment-linked operations increase the odds of being flagged as suspicious by factors of roughly 1.5-3.5. Qualitative evidence reveals uneven digitalization, fragmented data integration, and capacity gaps, especially in mid-sized banks, which limit the practical implementation of these risk-sensitive tools. The results justify targeted regulatory support for advanced analytics and provide a replicable framework for strengthening investment-related financial monitoring in Kazakhstan and comparable emerging markets.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)G21, G28, C38
-
References49
-
Tables11
-
Figures0
-
- Table 1. Key variables used in the modeling process
- Table 2. Software packages
- Table 3. Model variables and evaluation metrics
- Table 4. Case study analysis
- Table 5. Thematic insights on challenges and developments in financial crime monitoring
- Table 6. Variables and distribution targets
- Table 7. Logistic and multilevel logistic regression estimates for suspicious transaction prediction
- Table 8. Model fit statistics
- Table 9. Logistic and multilevel logistic regression results: suspicious transaction classification in Kazakhstani banks
- Table 10. Model performance & diagnostics
- Table 11. Bayesian model
-
- Alarab, I., Prakoonwit, S., & Nacer, M. I. (2020, June). Comparative analysis using supervised learning methods for anti-money laundering in Bitcoin. In Proceedings of the 2020 5th International Conference on machine learning technologies (pp. 11-17).
- Alexandre, C. R., & Balsa, J. (2023). Incorporating machine learning and a risk-based strategy in an anti-money laundering multi-agent system. Expert Systems with Applications, 217, 119500.
- Amoako, E. K. W., Boateng, V., Ajay, O., Adukpo, T. K., & Mensah, N. (2025). Exploring the role of machine learning and deep learning in anti-money laundering (AML) strategies within US financial industry: A systematic review of implementation, effectiveness, and challenges. Finance & Accounting Research Journal, 7(1), 22-36.
- Boeri, T. (2024). Transition with labor supply. In The Economics of Transition: The Fifth Nobel Symposium in Economics (pp. 94-143). London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.
- Dickinson, G. M. (2024). The Patterns of Digital Deception. BCL Review, 65, 2457.
- Ebenezer, A. B., Olutayo, B., Emmanuel, M., & Boye, F. O. (2024, September). Money Laundering Detection and Mitigation Using Decision Tree Ensembles. In 2024 IEEE SmartBlock4Africa (pp. 1-11). IEEE.
- Etembekov, R. K. (2021). Digital transformation of banking services in Russia. European Journal of Natural History, 1, 13-18.
- Gaisina, A., & Finger, M. (2025). Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs): a countermeasure to Anti-Money Laundering (AML) challenges posed by cryptocurrencies? Digital Finance, 7, 201-254.
- Gandhi, H., Tandon, K., Gite, S., Pradhan, B., & Alamri, A. (2024). Navigating the complexity of money laundering: anti–money laundering advancements with AI/ML insights. International Journal on Smart Sensing and Intelligent Systems, 17(1).
- Gaviyau, W., & Sibindi, A. B. (2023a). Customer due diligence in the fintech era: A bibliometric analysis. Risks, 11(1), 11.
- Gaviyau, W., & Sibindi, A. B. (2023b). Global anti-money laundering and combating terrorism financing regulatory framework: A critique. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 16(7), 313.
- Ilyina, A. (2022). Mechanism of Innovation and Investment Development in Modern Economy. Economic Affairs, 67(04s), 825-835.
- Jayasekara, S. D. (2022). Administrative model of financial intelligence units: an analysis of effectiveness of the AML/CFT regime. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 25(3), 511-525.
- Karabayev, E. B., Sembiyeva, L. M., Zeinelgabdin, A. B., Beisenova, L. Z., & Pankou, D. A. (2021). The role of external public audit in ensuring the financial stability of the budgets of developing countries. Public Policy and Administration, 20(1), 108-117.
- Kazantsev, A., Medvedeva, S., & Safranchuk, I. (2021). Between Russia and China: Central Asia in Greater Eurasia. Journal of Eurasian Studies, 12(1), 57-71.
- Khalilova, M. K., Davydov, V. A., & Niyazbekova, S. U. (2022). P2P lending as a new model of digital bank. In Ostrovskaya, V. N., & Bogoviz, A. V. (Eds.), Big data in the GovTech system (Vol. 110, pp. 177-187). Springer.
- Khamzaev, D. (2024). Regionalisation of International Initiatives: Case Study of the Eurasian Group on Combating Money Laundering and Financing of Terrorism (EAG). In Urinboyev, R. (Ed.), The Political Economy of Central Asian Law: A Law and Society Analysis (pp. 113-140). Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland.
- Khan, H. U., Malik, M. Z., & Nazir, S. (2024). Identifying the AI-based solutions proposed for restricting Money Laundering in Financial Sectors: Systematic Mapping. Applied Artificial Intelligence, 38(1), 2344415.
- Koziuk, V., Ivashuk, Y., Haida, Y., Oliinyk, V., Fursova, O., & Storozhenko, O. (2024). Preference factors regarding central bank digital currency anonymity: Behavioural, cultural, or institutional? Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 4(57), 9-21.
- Krapu, C., Stewart, R., & Rose, A. (2023). A review of Bayesian networks for spatial data. ACM Transactions on Spatial Algorithms and Systems, 9(1), 1-21.
- Kute, D. V., Pradhan, B., Shukla, N., & Alamri, A. (2021). Deep learning and explainable artificial intelligence techniques applied for detecting money laundering–a critical review. IEEE Access, 9, 82300-82317.
- Lacroix, R. (2023). Counter-terrorism Financing initiatives Utilised by the Russian Federation. In Romaniuk, S. N., Kaunert, C., & Fabe, A. P. H. (Eds.), Countering Terrorist and Criminal Financing (pp. 365-378). CRC Press.
- Lettieri, N., Guarino, A., Malandrino, D., & Zaccagnino, R. (2023). Knowledge mining and social dangerousness assessment in criminal justice: metaheuristic integration of machine learning and graph-based inference. Artificial Intelligence and Law, 31(4), 653-702.
- Long, Y., Kroeger, S., Zaeh, M. F., & Brintrup, A. (2025). Leveraging synthetic data to tackle machine learning challenges in supply chains: challenges, methods, applications, and research opportunities. International Journal of Production Research, 1-22.
- Manning, M., Wong, G. T., & Jevtovic, N. (2021). Investigating the relationships between FATF recommendation compliance, regulatory affiliations and the Basel Anti-Money Laundering Index. Security Journal, 34(3), 566-588.
- McNaughton, K. J. (2024). The tale of the Baltics: Experiences, challenges, and lessons from reforming their national Financial Intelligence Units (FIUs). Journal of Economic Criminology, 2, 100036.
- Mynbayeba, D., Nurgaliyeva, A., Alisheva, D., Duisenbayeva, B., & Kulumbetova, D. (2018). Application of the Holt-Winters Model for Predicting the Cost and Profitability of Bank Bonds. Journal of Applied Economic Sciences, 13(8).
- Nanyun, N. M., & Nasiri, A. (2021). Role of FATF on financial systems of countries: successes and challenges. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 24(2), 234-245.
- Nichkasova, Y., Sadvokassova, K., & Kayupov, N. (2021). Conceptual model for managing sustainable development of the financial market based on fuzzy cognitive maps: case study of Kazakhstan. International Journal of Economic Policy in Emerging Economies, 14(1), 1-38.
- Niyazbekova, S. U., Kodasheva, G. S., Dzholdosheva, T. Y., Goigova, M. G., & Meldebekova, A. A. (2022). Innovative banking services in the conditions of digitalization. In Ostrovskaya, V. N., & Bogoviz, A. V. (Eds.), Big data in the GovTech system (Vol. 110, pp. 73-79). Springer.
- Niyazbekova, S. U., Margatskaya, G. S., Patashkova, Y. S., Stepannikova, O. A., & Jazykbayeva, B. K. (2023). Analysis of Mortgage Lending in Conditions of Instability. In Popkova, E. G. (Ed.), Sustainable Development Risks and Risk Management: A Systemic View from the Positions of Economics and Law (pp. 615-618). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
- Osatiuk, A., Prokopenko, O., Vasylevska, H., Kucher, G., & Dereza, V. (2024). Financial instruments and their role in attracting investments. Multidisciplinary Reviews, 8(Special Issue), e2024spe079.
- Prokopenko, O. V., Biloshkurska, N. V., Biloshkurskyi, M. V., & Omelyanenko, V. A. (2019). The role of banks in national innovation system: general strategical analytics. Financial and Credit Activity Problems of Theory and Practice, 3(30), 26-35.
- Rafiq, M., & Sohail, M. K. (2023). Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Regulatory Technology: A Systematic Literature Review. Journal of Asian Development Studies, 12(3), 949-965.
- Rakhmetulayeva, S., Kulbayeva, A., Bolshibayeva, A., & Serbin, V. (2025). Identifying The Graphbased Typology Features for Machine Learning Models In Financial Fraud Detection. Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies, 135(9), 40-54.
- Reznik, O., Utkina, M., & Bondarenko, O. (2023). Financial intelligence (monitoring) as an effective way in the field of combating money laundering. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 26(1), 94-105.
- Rybalchenko, S., Lukianykhina, O., Alamanova, C., Saienko, V., & Sunduk, T. (2022). Anti-crisis management of banking institutions: Current problems and prospects for improvement. Financial and Credit Activity – Problems of Theory and Practice, 5(46), 29-39.
- Salina, A. P., Zhang, X., & Hassan, O. A. (2021). An assessment of the financial soundness of the Kazakh banks. Asian Journal of Accounting Research, 6(1), 23-37.
- Saxena, C. (2024). Identifying transaction laundering red flags and strategies for risk mitigation. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 27(6), 1063-1077.
- Schrepel, T., & Groza, T. (2023). The Adoption of Computational Antitrust by Agencies: 2nd Annual Report. Stanford Computational Antitrust, 3, 55.
- Shah, S. (2024). Financial inclusion and digital banking: Current trends and future directions. Premier Journal of Business and Management, 1.
- Shilibekova, B., & Plokhikh, R. (2025). Assessing readiness and breaking barriers to tourism digitalization: a case study of Kazakhstan. ECONOMIC Series of the Bulletin of the LN Gumilyov ENU, 2, 365-385.
- Spankulova, L., Aben, A., Nurmukhametov, N., & Zeinolla, S. (2025). Integration of ESG Principles into the Sustainable Development Strategy of Kazakhstan. Journal of Central Asian Studies, 23(1), 61-81.
- Sun, Q., & Ge, Z. (2021). A survey on deep learning for data-driven soft sensors. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, 17(9), 5853-5866.
- Verma, K. K., Singh, B. M., & Dixit, A. (2022). A review of supervised and unsupervised machine learning techniques for suspicious behavior recognition in intelligent surveillance system. International Journal of Information Technology, 14(1), 397-410.
- Vovchak, O., Rudevska, V., & Holub, R. (2018). Peculiarities of ensuring financial sustainability of the Ukrainian Banking System. Banks & Bank Systems, 13(1), 184-195.
- Yener, A. L., Christian, J. D., Chicheportiche, S. J., Rajasekaran, S., Ahmadov, P., & Castro, L. S. (2024). Digitalization of human development services in Europe and Central Asia. The World Bank Group.
- Zhamiyeva, R. M., Sultanbekova, G. B., Abzalbekova, M. T., Zhakupov, B. A., & Kozhanov, M. G. (2022). The role of financial investigations in combating money laundering. International Journal of Electronic Security and Digital Forensics, 14(2), 188-198.
- Zhou, H. Y. (2025). Regulating Crypto Money Laundering: An Assessment of Current Regulatory Responses and Potentials for Technology-Based Solutions. Stanford Journal of Blockchain Law & Policy, 8, 142.


