Evaluation of the economic effectiveness of investments in commercial real estate using the switch option

  • Received November 29, 2019;
    Accepted December 18, 2019;
    Published December 24, 2019
  • Author(s)
  • DOI
  • Article Info
    Volume 16 2019, Issue #4, pp. 315-324
  • Funding data
    Funder name: Rzeszow University of Technology, Poland
    Funder identifier: 813-02-66-999
    Award numbers:

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Deciding whether an investment should be made or not requires an evaluation of the investment’s effectiveness. The choice of evaluation methods is related to the basic objective conditioning the implementation of the investment project. It often happens that the conditions in which a specific investment has been formulated change and so does the basis for its implementation, and it is necessary to adapt it to the new conditions. These new conditions could be recognized during the exploitation of the project so it is hard to take them into consideration at the stage of planning. The paper aims to evaluate the investments in commercial real estate with the option of alternative way of usage. This evaluation was carried out using the classical (discounted) methods of economic efficiency of investments and real options. Two groups of pricing real options models were used in the study: binomial models and continuous-time models. Results based on varied valuation methods lead to different conclusions. Unlike the discount methods, the real option approach allows valuing the project flexibility (which cannot be valued by classical methods). This value of flexibility in certain conditions indicates what should be the path of development of the project related with the transformation of commercial real estate for other purposes.

view full abstract hide full abstract
    • Figure 1. Formation of benefits obtained from having shopping centre SC (top) and office space OS (bottom)
    • Figure 2. Benefits of changing the SC to OS (top) and OS to SC (bottom)
    • Figure 3. Decisions on the use of available space
    • Table 1. Data for calculating cash flow of shopping center
    • Table 2. Cash flows including the transformation of commercial space into office space
    • Table 3. Net cash flows and their present value in SC and OS