Comprehensive quantitative evaluation of municipal budget allocation efficiency: The Portuguese case
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/pmf.14(3).2025.05
-
Article InfoVolume 14 2025, Issue #3, pp. 59-73
- 13 Views
-
2 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Type of the article: Research Article
Abstract
The study provides a comprehensive quantitative evaluation of municipal budget allocation efficiency in Portugal over the period 2018–2022, based on a comparative and longitudinal analysis of financial data from 308 municipalities. Efficiency was assessed by examining the alignment between budget forecasts and actual financial execution. The results show that 77.6% of municipalities (n = 239) were classified as efficient in 2018, increasing to 82.1% (n = 253) in 2019 and 83.1% (n = 256) in 2020. However, a downward trend followed, with efficiency declining to 74.0% (n = 228) in 2021 and 73.7% (n = 227) in 2022. Over the five-year period, the average efficiency rate across all municipalities was 78.1%. In contrast, 21.9% of municipalities on average (ranging from 16.9% to 26.3%) consistently demonstrated inefficiencies in budget preparation and execution. The study identifies key contributing factors to inefficiency, including political interference, reliance on incremental budgeting approaches, and limited technical forecasting capacity. The data reveal persistent discrepancies between budgeted allocations and actual service demand, leading to resource misallocation and reduced fiscal credibility. Statistical patterns also indicate that municipalities with higher population densities and more diversified revenue sources tended to perform better in efficiency metrics. The findings support the conclusion that the adoption of rigorous, data-driven forecasting methodologies significantly improves financial planning outcomes and institutional trust. These results offer evidence-based recommendations for refining municipal financial management practices, particularly in settings subject to political and economic volatility.
Acknowledgment
This article is financed by Instituto Politécnico de Setúbal [Polytechnic Institute of Setúbal].
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)H61, H72, H74, H83
-
References50
-
Tables1
-
Figures3
-
- Figure 1. Heatmap – Number of inefficient municipalities by district (2018–2022)
- Figure 2. Coefficient of variation of municipal efficiency (2018–2022)
- Figure 3. The most (green) and least (red) efficient municipalities in the budget preparation process between 2018 and 2022
-
- Table A1. Index of inefficient municipalities (2018–2022)
-
- Ademmer, M., & Boysen-Hogrefe, J. (2022). The impact of forecast errors on fiscal planning and debt accumulation. Journal of Economics and Statistics, 242(2), 171-190.
- Afonso, A., & Fernandes, S. (2006). Measuring local government spending efficiency: Evidence for the Lisbon region. Regional Studies, 40(1), 39-53.
- Agasisti, T., & Sibiano P. (2012). Efficiency and heterogeneity of public spending in education among Italian regions. Journal of Public Affairs, 13(1), 12-22.
- Ahn, H., Neumann, L., & Novoa, N. (2012). Measuring the relative balance of DMUs. European Journal of Operational Research, 221(2), 417-423.
- Banker, R., Chang, H., & Natarajan, R. (2007). Estimating DEA technical and allocative inefficiency using aggregate cost or revenue data. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 27, 115-121.
- Barasa, E., Musiega, A., Hanson, K., Nyawira, L., Mulwa, A., Molyneux, S., Maina, I., Tsofa, B., Normand, C., & Jemutai, J. (2021). Level and determinants of county health system technical efficiency in Kenya: Two stage data envelopment analysis. Cost Effectiveness and Resource Allocation, 19(1), Article 78.
- Bardhan, P. (2022). Decentralization of governance and development. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 16(4), 185-205.
- Benito, B., Guillamón, M., & Bastida, F. (2015). Budget forecast deviations in municipal governments: Determinants and implications. Australian Accounting Review, 25(1), 45-70.
- Bhattacharyya, S., Issac, A., Girase, B., Guha, M., Schellenberg, J., & Avan, B. (2020). There is no link between resource allocation and use of local data: A qualitative study of district-based health decision-making in West Bengal, India. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(21), Article 8283.
- Boukari, M., & Veiga, F. (2018). Disentangling political and institutional determinants of budget forecast errors: A comparative approach. Journal of Comparative Economics, 46(4), 1030-1045.
- Brändle, T., & Elsener, M. (2024). Do fiscal rules matter? A survey of recent evidence. Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics, 160, Article 11.
- Buturac, G. (2022). Measurement of economic forecast accuracy: A systematic overview of the empirical literature. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 15(1), Article 1.
- Carneiro, L., & Costa, M. (2021). Factors associated with budget expenditure forecasting errors in Brazilian municipalities. Public Finance Notebooks, 21(2), 1-46.
- Ciaffi, G., Deleidi, M., & Domenico, L. (2024). Fiscal policy and public debt: Government investment is most effective to promote sustainability. Journal of Policy Modeling, 46(6), 1186-1209.
- Costa, C., & Rodrigues, M. (2007). Local governments budgeting: A Portuguese analysis of central dependency. EGPA Conference 2007.
- Danar, O. (2023). The efficiency of public sector programs and budget allocation: Evidence from Indonesian local government. International Journal of COMADEM, 26(4), 33-38.
- Derzayeva, G., & Akhmadieva, G. (2014). Budgetary policy efficiency of municipalities in the field of education. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 152, 1148-1153.
- Forestiere, C., & Pelizzo, R. (2008). Does the parliament make a difference? The role of the Italian parliament in financial policy. In R. Stapenhurst, R. Pelizzo, D.M. Olson & L. Von Trapp (Eds.), Legislative oversight and budgeting: A world perspective (pp. 276-278). World Bank.
- Gachithi, E. (2010). The challenges of budget implementation in public institutions: A case study of University of Nairobi (Master’s Thesis). Nairobi, Kenya: University of Nairobi.
- Golany, F., & Rousseau, J. (2012). Efficiency evaluation games. In F. Phillips & J. Rousseau (Eds.), Systems and Management Science by Extremal Methods (pp. 327-247). Boston, MA: Springer.
- Granizo, G., Moscatero, S., & Riofrio, M. (2024). Exploring the competencies, phases and dimensions of municipal administrative management towards sustainability: A systematic review. Sustainability, 16(14), Article 5991.
- Guzman, T., & Ermasova, N. (2022). Municipal fiscal stress, bankruptcies, and other financial emergencies. New York: Routledge.
- Hendry, D., & Ericsson, N. (2003). Understanding economic forecasts. MIT Press.
- Jiang, S., & Chi, Y. (2024). Impact of budget performance management reform on local fiscal relief. International Review of Economics & Finance, 93(B), 905-918.
- Johansson, T., & Siverbo, S. (2014). The appropriateness of tight budget control in public sector organizations facing budget turbulence. Management Accounting Research, 25(4), 271-283.
- Khaerani, T., Susilowati T., & Syafira, A. (2023). Analysis of the effectiveness and efficiency of expenditure budget implementation in Balikpapan City. Journal of World Science, 2(12), 2032-2038.
- Khan, A. (2019). Fundamentals of public budgeting and finance. Springer International Publishing.
- Krah, R., & Mertens, G. (2023). Financial transparency, trust and willingness to pay in local governments of sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 35(6), 100-120.
- Lewis, C. (2007). How to read a local budget and assess government performance. In A. Shah (Ed.), Local budgeting (pp. 179-211). World Bank.
- Liu, X. (2015). Public budgeting reform in China: Theory and practice. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.
- Lotfi, F., Ebrahimnejad, A., Vaez-Ghasemi, M., & Moghaddas, Z. (2019). Data envelopment analysis with R. Springer International Publishing.
- Machado, G., Crozatti, J., Moraes, V., Oliveira, B., & Silva, C. (2022). Impacts on the efficiency of public expenditure in the fundamental education of São Paulo cities through the expenditure element categories. Revista Ambiente Contábil, 14(1), 290-312.
- McQuestin, D., Noguchi, M., & Drew, J. (2022). The association between budget inaccuracy and technical efficiency in Australian local government. Public Money & Management, 42(4), 251-261.
- Mehdi, R., & Hafner C. (2014). Local government efficiency: The case of Moroccan municipalities. African Development Review, 26(1), 88-101.
- Mergoni, A., Emrouznejad, A., & Witte, K. (2024). Fifty years of data envelopment analysis. European Journal of Operational Research, 326(3), 389-412.
- Molinas, J., Pérez-Liñán, A., Hallerberg, M., & Morgan, A. (2009). Weakened policymaking process, deteriorating fiscal outcomes: The case of Paraguay. In M. Hallerberg, C. Scartascini, & E. Stein (Eds.), Who decides the budget? A political economy analysis of the budget process in Latin America (pp. 157-190). Inter-American Development Bank.
- Mou, H., Atkinson, M., & Marshall, J. (2019). Budgeting for efficiency? A case study of the public K-12 education systems of Canada. Applied Economics, 51(34), 3740-3757.
- Neal, R. (2012). Municipal management & finances: A primer for municipal officials and other lay persons to help better understand the basics of managing a small community. AuthorHouse.
- Nogueira, L., & Ramos, T. (2014). The integration of environmental practices and tools in the Portuguese local public administration. Journal of Cleaner Production, 76(1), 20-31.
- Okromtchedlishvili, I. (2022). Using data envelopment analysis (DEA) for measuring efficiency in the defense sector. Defense and Security Studies, 3, 83-100.
- Ou, Z., Zeng, F., & Zhan, X. (2020). Does public spending structure affect the efficiency of spending? Evidence from a panel Tobit model for Chinese provinces. International Journal of Management, Economics and Social Sciences, 9(3), 206-223.
- Paina, L., Young, R., Oladapo, O., Leandro, J., Chen, Z., & Igusa, T. (2024). Prospective policy analysis: A critical interpretive synthesis review. Health Policy and Planning, 39(4), 429-441.
- Ratner, S., Lychev, A., & Krivonozhko, V. (2024). Data envelopment analysis-based approach to improving of the budget allocation system for decarbonization targets. Economies, 12(7), Article 160.
- Soares, R. (2024). Evaluating the efficiency of public expenditure in municipal waste collection: A comparative study of Portuguese municipalities. Environmental Economics, 15(1), 203-216.
- Soares, R., Nunes, A., Pinheiro, P., Kaizeler, A., & Martins, V. (2024). Asymmetries in energy consumption: Efficiency of public spending across Portuguese municipalities. Public and Municipal Finance, 13(2), 110-128.
- Trenovski, B., & Marjan, N. (2015). Cost-benefit analysis of performance based budgeting implementation. CEA Journal of Economics, 10(2), 5-44.
- Vanderbilt, D. (1977). Budgeting in local government: Where are we now? Public Administration Review, 37(5), 538-542.
- Volden, G. (2019). Public funding, perverse incentives, and counterproductive outcomes. International Journal of Managing Projects in Business, 12(2), 466-486.
- Yahelska, K., Tropina, V., Khomutenko, A., Petlenko, Y., Lantukh, K., & Kryhan, Y. (2021). Comparative analysis of methods for forecasting budget indicators. Studies of Applied Economics, 39(3), 1-12.
- Yatiman, N., & Pujiyono, A. (2013). Analisis efisiensi teknis anggaran belanja sektor kesehatan pemerintah daerah kabupaten/kota di provinsi daerah istimewa Yogyakarta tahun 2008–2010 [Analysis of the technical efficiency of the health sector budget of local governments in districts/cities in the special region of Yogyakarta province from 2008 to 2010]. Diponegoro Journal of Economics, 2(1), 7-19. (In Indonesian).