AI ecosystem pillars and economic growth: Implications for knowledge economy architecture from AI vibrancy subindices
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/kpm.10(1).2026.06
-
Article InfoVolume 10 2026, Issue #1, pp. 66-87
- 10 Views
-
3 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Type of the article: Research Article
AI is widely regarded by the IMF and the World Bank as a catalyst for growth. AI should be understood as a multidimensional socio-technical system embedded across institutions, industries, and society. Its economic contribution depends on which pillars of the national AI system expand (e.g., R&D capacity, infrastructure, governance, or social acceptance). For this reason, the seven pillars of AI development are measured by the AI Vibrancy subindices, which help avoid reliance on a single composite indicator that may conceal offsetting effects. This study examines how different pillars of the national AI ecosystem shape the architecture of the knowledge economy and its economic outcomes by estimating heterogeneous within-country associations between GDP per capita and seven AI ecosystem pillars, operationalized through AI Vibrancy subindices, using a balanced panel of 36 countries with complete data over the period 2020–2023. Fixed- and random-effects models are estimated using heteroskedasticity-robust and Driscoll-Kraay standard errors. The results indicate that, within countries over time, the R&D (β = –5.676, p < 0.001) and Infrastructure (β = –16.306, p < 0.001) subindices have strong and statistically significant negative associations with GDP per capita, while Public Opinion shows an adverse effect that is significant at the 5% level under heteroskedasticity-robust inference (β = –9.126, p = 0.040) and marginally significant under Driscoll-Kraay inference (p = 0.054). Responsible AI exhibits a marginally positive association (β = 5.773, p = 0.065) in the Driscoll-Kraay specification, whereas Economy, Education, and Policy & Government show no significant within-country effects.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)O33, O47, L86, C23
-
References63
-
Tables11
-
Figures0
-
- Table 1. Variables and their sources
- Table 2. Descriptive statistics (from R Studio)
- Table 3. Summary table of results of FE and RE models
- Table 4. Outputs of the Driscoll-Kraay and cluster-robust standard errors
- Table 5. System GMM estimation results
- Table 6. Descriptive statistics
- Table 7. Panel regression results for GDP per capita (square root transformation) and Yeo-Johnson-transformed AI Vibrancy subindexes
- Table 8. Fixed effects model with heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors
- Table 9. Fixed effects model with Driscoll-Kraay robust standard errors
- Table 10. Country-specific fixed effects from the fixed effects model
- Table 11. One-way fixed effects model with time dummies and Driscoll-Kraay standard errors
-
- Abou-Moghli, A. (2025). Sustainable digital transformation in the energy sector: The role of artificial intelligence training in achieving Jordan’s green growth strategy. Environmental Economics, 17(1), 1-11.
- Ayu Gusti, M., Satrianto, A., Candrianto, Juniardi, E., & Fitra, H. (2024). Artificial intelligence for employee engagement and productivity. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 22(3), 174-184.
- Bartosova, V., Drobyazko, S., Bielialov, T., Nechyporuk, L., & Dzhyhora, O. (2023). Company strategic change management in the open innovation system. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity, 9(2), 100087.
- Bashynska, I. (2025). Ethical aspects of AI use in the circular economy. AI & Society.
- Bouguerroumi, H., & Belarbi, Y. (2025). Cyclicality and Economic Growth Dynamics: Business Cycles’ Typologization, Dating, and Matching with Oil Price Fluctuations. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 9(1), 59-73.
- Bugrov, V., W. Sitnicki, M., & Serbin, O. (2021). Strategic management of creative industries: A case study of university information institutions. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 19(2), 453-467.
- Cerutti, E., García Pascual, A., Kido, Y., Li, L., Melina. G., Tavares, M. M., & Wingender, P. (2025). The Global Impact of AI: Mind the Gap (IMF Working Paper No. 25/76).
- Chandran, K. R. P., & Tholath, D. I. (2025). Digital insurance acceptance among older adults in the context of AI. Insurance Markets and Companies, 16(1), 131-145.
- Dabija, D. C., & Frau, M. (2025). Leveraging artificial intelligence in marketing: Trend or the new normal? Oeconomia Copernicana, 15(4), 1173-1181.
- El Massaoudi, E. M., El Hammoumi, A., Seghyar, N., & El Ouali, A. (2025). Digital transformation and improvement of management control: Empirical study in financial institutions. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 22(3), 455-469.
- Filippucci, F., Gal, P., Jona-Lasinio, C., Leandro, A., & Nicoletti, G. (2024). The impact of Artificial Intelligence on productivity, distribution and growth: Key mechanisms, initial evidence and policy challenges. OECD Artificial Intelligence Papers, 15.
- Financial Stability Board (FSB). (2024). The Financial Stability Implications of Artificial Intelligence. Financial Stability Board Reports to the G20.
- Ganushchak, I., Bashynska, I., Ognjanovic, I., Duda, J., & Kusa, R. (2025). AI-driven approaches to bridging the digital divide and advancing smart circular enterprises. Journal of Intelligent and Fuzzy Systems, 0(0).
- Golubtsov, D., Kedziora, J., Kozhakhmetova, A., & Kedziora, D. (2025). Assessing the impact of digital technologies and artificial intelligence (AI) on the efficiency of supply chain. Economics and Sociology, 18(1), 149-173.
- Hadouga, H. (2023). Leadership in Agriculture: Artificial Intelligence for Modelling and Forecasting Growth in the Industry. Business Ethics and Leadership, 7(3), 13-19.
- Haley, P. (2025). Artificial Intelligence and Ethical Dimensions of Automated Traffic Enforcement: Implications for Public Health, Healthcare Equity, and Social Justice. Health Economics and Management Review, 6(2), 32-49.
- Ibadildin, N., Kenzhin, Z., Yeshenkulova, G., Ismailova, R., Nurguzhina, A., Nassanbekova, S., & Kadyrova, A. (2025). Artificial intelligence in project management: A bibliometric analysis. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 23(2), 252-264.
- Jarzębowski, S., Bozhenko, V., Didorenko, K., Tkachenko, O., Blyznyukov, A., Melnyk, M., & Cieslik, J. (2024). The Impact of Digitalisation on the Competitiveness of European Countries. SocioEconomic Challenges, 8(3), 238-261.
- Kajda, K., & Karwot, J. (2025). The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Revolutionizing Industrial Automation for Municipal Waste Management in Industry 4.0. Green Transition and Sustainable Development, 1(1), 37-63.
- Kergroach, S. & J. Héritier (2025). Emerging divides in the transition to artificial intelligence (OECD Regional Development Papers No. 147). OECD Publishing, Paris.
- Khaddam, A., & Alhanatleh, H. (2024). Role of artificial intelligence and BIG DATA capabilities on fintech services: Value co-creation theory. Innovative Marketing, 20(4), 219-233.
- Khrais, L. (2025). Bridging gaps in InsurTech and e-commerce integration: Insights from Saudi Arabia. Insurance Markets and Companies, 16(1), 64-73.
- Kirichok, O., Orlovska, Y., Zhanseitova, G., Oriekhova, A., Babaiev, D., Havrylenko, O., & Vasylieva, T. (2025). Bridging digital innovation and energy justice: The role of artificial intelligence in advancing energy equity. Environmental Economics, 16(4), 166-181.
- Koldovskyi, A., Babenko, K., Shafranova, K., & Dyvynska, Y. (2025). The Role of AI in Enhancing Sustainable Business Leadership and Organizational Resilience. Business Ethics and Leadership, 9(2), 188-199.
- Kozhushko, I. (2023). Transformation of the Financial Services Industry in the Context of Digital Economy. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 7(4), 189-200.
- Kritikos, I., Sarantopoulos, A., Roumeliotis, A., Vasiliades, J., & Matsinas, I. (2025). Unlocking the Potential of Artificial Intelligence in Pharma Research and Development: Insights from Investor and Researcher Perspectives. Health Economics and Management Review, 6(2), 1-16.
- Kumar, K. S. D., & Kumar, J. P. S. (2024). Efficiency assessment and trends in the insurance industry: A bibliometric analysis of DEA application. Insurance Markets and Companies, 15(1), 83-98.
- Kusairi, S., Wong, Z. Y., Wahyuningtyas, R., & Sukemi, M. N. (2023). Impact of digitalisation and foreign direct investment on economic growth: Learning from developed countries. Journal of International Studies, 16(1), 98-111.
- Kuzior, A., Bielialov, T., Morozova, O., Vasiltsova, O., Rubanov, P., Holub, I., & Lyeonov, S. (2025). Does a country’s energy security increase with advances in government AI readiness? An empirical panel study. Environmental Economics, 16(4), 182-196.
- Kuzior, A., Marszałek-Kotzur, I., Kurovska, Y., & Chvankin, Y. (2024). The Role of Digital Economy in Transformation of Public Health: Modeling and Analysis. Health Economics and Management Review, 5(4), 91-109.
- Lazaroiu, G., & Rogalska, E. (2023). How generative artificial intelligence technologies shape partial job displacement and labor productivity growth. Oeconomia Copernicana, 14(3), 703-706.
- Lazaroiu, G., Gedeon, T., Valaskova, K., Vrbka, J., Šuleř, P., Zvarikova, K., Kramarova, K., Rowland, Z., Stehel, V., Gajanova, L., Horák, J., Grupac, M., Caha, Z., Blazek, R., Kovalova, E., & Nagy, M. (2024). Cognitive digital twin-based Internet of Robotic Things, multi-sensory extended reality and simulation modeling technologies, and generative artificial intelligence and cyber-physical manufacturing systems in the immersive industrial metaverse. Equilibrium. Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy, 19(3), 719-748.
- Liu, Y., & Wang, H. (2024). Who on Earth Is Using Generative AI? (World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 10870). Digital Development Global Practice.
- Lyeonov, S., Draskovic, V., Kubaščikova, Z., & Fenyves, V. (2024). Artificial intelligence and machine learning in combating illegal financial operations: Bibliometric analysis. Human Technology, 20(2), 325-360.
- Murko, E., Babšek, M., & Aristovnik, A. (2024). Artificial intelligence and public governance models in socioeconomic welfare: some insights from Slovenia. Administratie si Management Public, 43, 41-60.
- Mursalov, M., Yarovenko, H., & Vasilyeva, T. (2023). Entrepreneurial Ecosystem and digitalization: Relationship and Synergy of Development. In: Strielkowski, W. (Eds.), Leadership, Entrepreneurship and Sustainable Development Post COVID-19. NILBEC 2022. Springer Proceedings in Business and Economics (pp. 109-127). Springer, Cham.
- Oe, H., Yamaoka, Y., & Weeks, M. (2025). Public-Private Partnerships in Traditional Industries: A Comparative Governance Framework for Regional Revitalization in Japan and Central Europe. Public Governance, Regulation and Law, 1(1), 1-15.
- Pilelienė, L., & Bogoyavlenska, Y. (2025). Artificial intelligence in influencer marketing: Current researchscape, trends and insights from a bibliometric review. Equilibrium. Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy, 20(2), 583-611.
- Polishchuk, Y. (2023). Fintech future trends. In J. Lubacha, B. Mäihäniemi, & R. Wisła (Eds.), The European digital economy: Drivers of digital transition and economic recovery (pp. 204-220). Routledge.
- Potwora, M., Vdovichena, O., Semchuk, D., Lipych, L., & Saienko, V. (2024). The use of artificial intelligence in marketing strategies: Automation, personalization and forecasting. Journal of Management World, 2, 41-49.
- Prieto-Gutierrez, J.-J., Segado-Boj, F., & Da Silva França, F. (2023). Artificial intelligence in social science: A study based on bibliometrics analysis. Human Technology, 19(2), 149-162.
- Prokopenko, O., & Omelyanenko, V. (2020). Intellectualization of the phased assessment and use of the potential for internationalizing the activity of clusters of cultural and creative industries in the Baltic Sea regions. TEM Journal, 9(3), 1068-1075.
- Prokopenko, O., Eremenko, Y., & Omelyanenko, V. (2014). Role of international factor in innovation ecosystem formation. Economic Annals-XXI, 3-4, 4-7.
- Reuters. (2025). AI economic gains likely to outweigh emissions cost, says IMF.
- Sahnouni, M., & Kadri, M. (2025). Investments in ICT in the Telecommunications Sector: A Strategic Imperative for Organizational Changes in Response to Market Transformations. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 9(2), 112-122.
- Samusevych, Y. V., Novikov, V. V., Artyukhov, A. Y., & Vasylieva, T. A. (2021). Convergence trends in the “economy – education – digitalization – national security” chain. Naukovyi Visnyk Natsionalnoho Hirnychoho Universytetu, 6, 177-183.
- Schinello, S. (2025). Challenges and opportunities in using artificial intelligence in creative economy: Insights from expert interviews. Economics and Sociology, 18(1), 199-216.
- Sitnicki, M. W., Horbas, I., Derkach, O., Flowers, A., Wielewska, I., Tucki, K., Zuzek, D. K., & Pimenov, S. (2024). Development and Support of Ukrainian Domestic Entrepreneurship in the Knowledge Economy. Sustainability, 16(13), 5682.
- Stanford University. (n.d.). Global AI Vibrancy Tool - AI Index. Stanford University Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence.
- Tymoshenko, M., Saienko, V., Serbov, M., Shashyna, M., & Slavkova, O. (2023). The impact of Industry 4.0 on modelling energy scenarios of the developing economies. Financial and Credit Activity-Problems of Theory and Practice, 1(48), 336-350.
- Ustik, T., Karmazinova, V., Shurpa, S., Zhuk, O., Boiko, O., Radkevych, L. (2023). The Impact of Digitalization on Marketing Communications: New Challenges for Branding and Advertising Business. Wseas Transactions on Information Science and Applications, 20, 344-355.
- World Bank. (n.d.). Agriculture & Rural Development. World Bank Open Data.
- Xuan, H. V. T., Huan, V. M., & Su, L. H. (2025). Mapping research trends in online shopping behavior during the fourth industrial revolution: A bibliometric analysis. Innovative Marketing, 21(4), 216-231.
- Xue, L., Satpayeva, Z., Tyulkubayeva, A., & Kangalakova, D. (2025). Impact of artificial intelligence applications on enterprise market value: Evidence from Chinese enterprises. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 22(4), 303-317.
- Yarovenko, H., Horbachova, O., Bylbas, R., & Latysh, D. (2025). Digitalization as a Socio-Economic Challenge: Modeling the Impact on the Level of Cybercrime Considering Socio-Economic, Technological and Institutional Factors. SocioEconomic Challenges, 9(2), 282-315.
- Yarovenko, H., Kuzior, A., Norek, T., & Lopatka, A. (2024a). The future of artificial intelligence: Fear, hope or indifference? Human Technology, 20(3), 611-639.
- Yarovenko, H., Vasilyeva, T., Ustinovichius, L., & Remsei, S. (2024b). Illicit practices: Experience of developed countries. Journal of International Studies, 17(2), 146-177.
- Yefimenko, A., Boronos, V., Serpeninova, Yu., & Koldovskyi, A. (2025a). Innovative and Technological Determinants of Corruption Reduction: How do Knowledge and Technology Contribute to Public Integrity and Transparency? Knowledge Economy and Lifelong Learning, 1(1), 21-34.
- Yurchyk, H., Mishchuk, H., & Bilan, Y. (2023). Government assistance programs for internally displaced persons: assessing the impact on economic growth and labour market. Administratie si Management Public, 41, 201-218.
- Zaryczańska, K., & Karwot, J. (2025). Analysis of Occupational Safety and Health at the Construction Site Based on Images Acquired from Various Sources Using Artificial Intelligence. Safety and Security Advances, 1(1), 1-17.
- Ziane, A., Bouziani, A., & Moumni, S. (2025). Entrepreneurship and Innovation: Driving Economic Growth. SocioEconomic Challenges, 9(1), 219-232.
- Zimosz, P., & Ober, J. (2025). Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Education. Knowledge Economy and Lifelong Learning, 1(2), 77-98.
- Zolkover, A., & Ovcharenko, P. (2024). Modelling a comprehensive assessment of the level of innovation security. Smart Economy, Entrepreneurship and Security, 2(1), 50-57.


