Managers’ sustainable leadership competencies across Hungary, Kazakhstan, and Türkiye: Effects of personal, organizational, and industry factors
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/ppm.23(4).2025.34
-
Article InfoVolume 23 2025, Issue #4, pp. 467-485
- 14 Views
-
3 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Type of the article: Research Article
Abstract
Sustainable leadership has become one of the widely addressed topics over the last decade, both in business and academia. This paper examines how personal, organizational, and industry characteristics influence sustainable leadership competencies across Turkic nations and how the country variable moderates these relationships. The study utilized the results of a comprehensive leadership assessment based on managers’ involvement in a business simulation, operated by artificial intelligence and rooted in scientific management. Assessment results of 1,756 managers from Hungary (N = 695), Kazakhstan (N = 647), and Türkiye (N = 414), employed in manufacturing and construction, education and research, finance, production and trade, information technologies, public relations and services, were analyzed. The two-step approach to structural equation modeling was implemented using Python software. The results showed that strategic and normative competences were partially dependent on managers’ gender (β = 1.450, p = 0.022), age (β = 5.678, p < 0.001; β = –3.587, p < 0.001), tenure (β = 3.767, p < 0.001; β = –1.898; p = 0.020) and industry (β = 1.194, p = 0.031; β = 3.092, p = 0.001), whereas interpersonal and anticipatory competencies remained unaffected. The country demonstrated a significant positive moderation in the relationships associated with normative competence (β = 3.260, p = 0.039) and interpersonal competence (β = 5.667, p = 0.041). In contrast, it exhibits a noteworthy negative moderation in strategic competence (β = –3.665, p = 0.043) and systems thinking competence (β = –3.853, p = 0.006). The moderation effect between the managers’ age, tenure, industry, and sustainable competencies was most pronounced in Kazakhstan, followed by Hungary, and least in Türkiye. This nuanced understanding highlights the diverse impact the country has on different aspects of competence, underscoring the importance of context in these relationships.
Acknowledgment
This research has been funded by the Science Committee of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Grant No. AP22687001) within the project titled “Designing a Conceptual Model of Managers’ Leadership Competencies in Kazakhstan through the Gender Potential Prism”.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)J24, Q01
-
References53
-
Tables12
-
Figures1
-
- Figure 1. Conceptual model
-
- Table 1. Sustainable leadership competencies and their subconstructs
- Table 2. Demographics
- Table 3. Reliability and convergent validity indices
- Table 4. Evaluation of H1 about the impact of the industry on managers’ normative competence
- Table 5. Testing H2 about the positive impact of the longer tenure on systems thinking competence
- Table 6. Relationships between strategic competence and tenure
- Table 7. Influence of managers’ age on their anticipatory and strategic competencies
- Table 8. Testing correlations between managers’ gender and their normative and interpersonal competencies
- Table 9. Testing the moderating effect of the country variable
- Table 10. Testing the moderating effects across Hungary, Kazakhstan, and Türkiye
- Table A1. Descriptive statistics
- Table B1. Correlation matrix between clusters
-
- Alonso-Almeida, M., Perramon, J., & Bagur-Femenias, L. (2017). Leadership styles and corporate social responsibility management: Analysis from a gender perspective. Business Ethics, the Environment, and Responsibility, 26(2), 147-161.
- Alvarez-García, J., Hormiga-Pérez, E., Sarango-Lalangui, P. O., & del Río-Rama, M. D. L. C. (2022). Leaders’ sustainability competences and small and medium-sized enterprises outcomes: The role of social entrepreneurial orientation. Sustainable Development, 30(5), 927-943.
- Anderson, J. C., & Gerbing, D. W. (1988). Structural equation modeling in practice: A review and recommended two-step approach. Psychological Bulletin, 103(3), 411-423.
- Angelakis, A., Inwinkl, P., Berndt, A., Ozturkcan, S., Zelenajova, A., & Rozkopal, V. (2023). Gender differences in leaders’ crisis communication: A sentiment-based analysis of German higher education leaderships’ online posts. Studies in Higher Education, 49(4), 609-622.
- Archer, T., Jansson, B., & Olsen, K. (2025). Effect of age upon leadership attributes from recruitment instrument: A selective developmental trajectory. Clinical and Experimental Psychology, 1(1), Article 1000106.
- Avery, G. (2005). Leadership for sustainable futures: Achieving success in a competitive world. Edward Elgar Publishing.
- Bencsik, A., & Belas, Y. (2024). Characteristics of sustainable leadership in international comparison. Economics and Sociology Journal, 17(4), 272-294.
- Bencsik, A., & Berke, Sz. (2023). Sustainable leadership in practice in Hungary. Proceedings of the 19th European Conference on Management Leadership and Governance, UK, 19(1), 9-19.
- Bencsik, A., & Pangsy-Kania, S. (2023). Sustainable leadership practices based on the logic of the honeybee pyramid – Comparison of Hungarian and Polish SMEs. Sustainability, 15(17), Article 13103.
- Brundiers, K., Barth, M., Cebrián, G., Cohen, M., Diaz, L., Doucette-Remington, S., Dripps, W., Habron, G., Harré, N., Jarchow, M., Losch, K., Michel, J., Mochizuki, Y., Rieckmann, M., Parnell, R., Walker, P., & Zint, M. (2021). Key competencies in sustainability in higher education – Toward an agreed-upon reference framework. Sustainability Science, 16, 13-29.
- Buzady, Z., & Lipovka, A. (2024). Kazakhstan: Going global in a post-Soviet country. In B. Gehrke, M.-T. Claes, I. Aust-Gronarz, D. Pauknerova, & R. Bell. (Eds.), Global leadership practices. Competencies for managing in a complex world (pp. 193-209). Edward Elgar Publishing.
- Çuhadar, S., & Rudnak, I. (2022). Importance of sustainable leadership and sustainable leadership practices among middle-level Hungarian managers. Journal of Management/Vadyba, 38(2), 101-111.
- Dentoni, D., Blok, V., Lans, T., & Wesselink, R. (2012). Developing human capital for agri-food firms’ multi-stakeholder interactions. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, 15 (Special Issue A), 61-68.
- Diaz-Fernandez, M., Lopez-Cabrales, A., & Valle-Cabrera, R. (2024). Sustainable strategies, employee competencies and social outcomes: Are they aligned? International Journal of Manpower, 45(7), 1426-1449.
- Dragoni, L., Oh, I., Tesluk, P.E., Moore, O.A., VanKatwyk, P., & Hazucha, J. (2014). Developing leaders’ strategic thinking through global work experience: The moderating role of cultural distance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 99(5), 867-882.
- Dragoni, L., Oh, I., Vankatwyk, P., & Tesluk, P. E. (2011). Developing executive leaders: The relative contribution of cognitive ability, personality, and the accumulation of work experience in predicting strategic thinking competency. Personnel Psychology, 64(4), 829-864.
- Eberz, S., Lang, S., Breitenmoser, P., & Niebert, K. (2023). Taking the lead into sustainability: Decision makers’ competencies for a greener future. Sustainability, 15(6), Article 4986.
- Fauzi, Basrowi, Wulandari, & Irviani, R. (2025). Fostering sustainability through leadership and employee personality traits. Sustainable Futures, 9, Article 100502.
- Fligby. (2024). Gameplay data research. ALEAS Group.
- Galleli, B., Hourneaux, F. Jr, & Munck, L. (2020). Sustainability and human competences: A systematic literature review. Benchmarking: An International Journal, 27(7), 1981-2004.
- Glińska-Neweś, A., Escher, I., Józefowicz, B., & Łuka, A. (2020). Managing strategic paradoxes: The influence of demographic characteristics of decision-makers. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 33(5), 835-858.
- Griffin, D., Guedhami, O., Li, K., & Lu, G. (2021). National culture and the value implications of corporate environmental and social performance. Journal of Corporate Finance, 71, Article 102123.
- Grigorescu, A., Munteanu, I., Dumitrica, C.-D., & Lincaru, C. (2023). Development of a green competency matrix based on civil servants’ perception of sustainable development expertise. Sustainability, 15(18), Article 13913.
- Hahn, R., Pioch, T., Reimsbach, D., & Schiemann, F. (2025). What drives carbon-reducing investments? A vignette experiment on managers’ decision-making from a multilevel perspective. Business Strategy and the Environment, 34(3), 3008-3026.
- Hallinger, P., & Suriyankietkaew, S. (2018). Science mapping of the knowledge base on sustainable leadership, 1990–2018. Sustainability, 10(12), Article 4846.
- Hargreaves, A., & Fink, D. (2004). The seven principles of sustainable leadership. Educational Leadership, 61(7), 8-13.
- Hopkins, M. M., & Bilimoria, D. (2008). Social and emotional competencies predicting success for male and women executives. Journal of Management Development, 27(1), 13-35.
- Jordan, S. W., Servi, J. P., & Manderscheid, S. V. (2025). Gender insights on team-oriented leadership: Findings from the Globe Project. International Journal of Business and Applied Social Science, 11(1), 1-15.
- Kachniewska, M., & Para, A. (2023). Feminine vs. masculine: Expectations of leadership styles in hotels during the COVID-19 pandemic. Sustainability, 15(13), Article 10602.
- Knight, B., & Paterson, F. (2018). Behavioural competencies of sustainability leaders: An empirical investigation. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 31(3), 557-580.
- Larsson, G., Molnar, M.M., Tinnerholm Ljungberg, H., & Björklund, C. (2023). Leadership through the subordinates’ eye: Perceptions of leader behaviors in relation to age and gender. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 44(1), 18-33.
- Li, D., & Maqsood, U. S. (2025). CEO’s demographic, governance, and career factors in environmental and sustainable performance: Evidence from China M&A cases. Business Ethics, the Environment and Responsibility.
- Liao, Y. (2022). Sustainable leadership: A literature review and prospects for future research. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, Article 1045570.
- Lipovka, A., Korolyova, N., Nugmanova, M., & Salimzhanova, A. (2021). Comparative influence of gender, age, industry and management level on communication. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 19(2), 170-182.
- Liu, L. (2019). Top management characteristics, green supply chain management and corporate performance – Moderating effects of competition intensity. Journal of Human Resource and Sustainability Studies, 7(1), 55-71.
- Ma, Y., Zhang, Q., Yin, Q., & Wang, B. (2019). The influence of top managers on environmental information disclosure: The moderating effect of company’s environmental performance. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 16(7), Article 1167.
- Mahmood, M., Uddin, M.A., Ostrovskiy, A., & Orazalin, N. (2020). Effectiveness of business leadership in the Eurasian context: Empirical evidence from Kazakhstan. Journal of Management Development, 39(6), 793-809.
- Nagahi, M., Hossain, N., Amrani, S., Jaradat, R., Khademibami, L., Goerger, S., & Buchanan, R. (2022). Investigating the influence of demographics and personality types on practitioners’ level of systems thinking skills. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 69(6), 3923-3937.
- Nagahi, M., Hossain, N., Jaradat, R.M., & Grogan, S. (2019). Moderation effect of managerial experience on the level of systems-thinking skills. 2019 IEEE International Systems Conference (SysCon), 1-5.
- Nagalakshmi, M.V.N, Sai Sri Charan, Y.V.N., Panchaaariya, R.O., Padma, S., & Awasthi, S. (2025). Sustainable business practices and leadership as catalyst for employee innovation in IT industry. Journal of Information Systems Engineering and Management, 10(23s), 911-919.
- Navia, J.M.A., Plazas, E.R., & Diaz, Y.C. (2019). Leadership and social responsibility from the perspective of gender. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 17(2), 303-312.
- Organization of Turkic States. (n.d.). History of the organization.
- Ozen, A., & Ayla, E. (2024). Sustainable leadership competencies at the top: An agenda for the future. Journal of Electrical Systems, 20(4s), 1595-1601.
- Padhi, D., Chavan, P. S., & Mitra, R. (2018). Understanding systems thinking from the perspectives of experience and diversity. 2018 IEEE Tenth International Conference on Technology for Education (T4E), 122-125.
- Pfaff, L. A., Boatwright, K. J., Potthoff, A. L., Finan, C., Ulrey, L. A., & Huber, D. M. (2013). Perceptions of women and men leaders following 360-degree feedback evaluations. Performance Improvement Quarterly, 26(1), 35-56.
- Remišová, A., & Lašáková, A. (2015). Ethical leadership styles of future managers in Central and Eastern European сountries. In I. Management Association (Ed.), Human Rights and Ethics: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications (pp. 892-911). IGI Global Scientific Publishing.
- Streufert, S., Pogash, R., Piasecki, M., & Post, G. M. (1990). Age and management team performance. Psychology and Aging, 5(4), 551-559.
- Suriyankietkaew, S., Krittayaruangroj, K., & Iamsawan, N. (2022). Sustainable leadership practices and competencies of SMEs for sustainability and resilience: A community-based social enterprise study. Sustainability, 14(10), Article 5762.
- Tavitiyaman, P., Weerakit, N., & Ryan, B. (2014). Leadership competencies for hotel general managers: The differences in age, education, and hotel characteristics. International Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Administration, 15(2), 191-216.
- Tezcan, Ö., & Kuleyin, B. (2021). Evaluating port operation managers’ competencies related to the port environmental sustainability performance. Pomorstvo, 35(1), 141-149.
- Wiek, A., Withycombe, L., & Redman, C. L. (2011). Key competencies in sustainability: A reference framework for academic program development. Sustainability Science, 6, 203-218.
- Wimmer, A., Buzady, Z., Csesznak, A., & Szentesi, P. (2022). Intuitive and analytical decision-making skills analysed through a flow developing serious game. Journal of Decision Systems, 31(sup1), 4-17.
- Yangil, F. M., & Şahin, M. D. (2019). Sürdürülebilir liderlik ölçeği: Geçerlik ve güvenirlik analizi [The sustainable leadership scale: Validity and reliability analysis]. Business and Management Studies: An International Journal, 7(5), 2124-2147. (In Turkish).


